Your AI agent buys the wrong thing and the shop won't refund because your agent placed the order. Who pays?
AI can't be held liable for anything in law, so the answer is always a person or a business:
- You, if you gave the agent your card. The payment probably counts as authorised, so your bank doesn't have to refund it.
- The shop, if its own agent or chatbot got it wrong.
- The company that built the agent, depending on its terms.
Credit cards give you more protection than debit cards, so if you let an agent pay for things, I'd give it a credit card.
Some companies have now gone further and stopped agents buying from them at all.
On 11 November United Airlines changed its contract of carriage to ban AI agents from buying, changing or servicing tickets. It applies even when you approve each step yourself, and United can cancel a booking an agent made without notice. An agent can still search for flights and show you prices, as long as you make the purchase.
In the UK, HSBC, Nationwide, NatWest, Barclays and Lloyds have reportedly moved to block AI agents from customer accounts. One of the reasons given is that there are no clear rules on who is liable when an agent mishandles a customer's money.
So before you let an agent pay for something, check that the company allows it.